How to Host a Successful Garage Sale (and What to Do With Leftovers)

Anne Callender • May 9, 2025
A cardboard sign that says garage sale on it

How to Host a Successful Garage Sale (and What to Do With Leftovers)

Spring is here in Colorado, which means garage sale season is in full swing. Whether you're in Boulder, Broomfield, or Louisville, now is the perfect time to declutter your home, earn a little extra money, and make space for a fresh start. But how do you plan a garage sale that actually works—and what should you do with everything that doesn’t sell?


This guide walks you through how to organize a successful garage sale and what to do with the items that don’t make it off the driveway.


Step 1: Start by Decluttering

Begin by going room by room (i.e. garage, basement, closets, attic) and pull out anything you no longer use. Sort items into three categories: sell, donate, or discard. If something is broken or too worn out to sell or donate, it’s time to get rid of it.


For large, bulky, or unusable items, Colorado Junk Runners offers affordable junk removal services in Lafayette, Erie, Louisville, and surrounding areas. Let us handle the heavy lifting so you can focus on what matters.


Step 2: Organize and Price Your Items

Once you’ve selected the items to sell, organize them into categories such as tools, toys, kitchenware, and outdoor gear. Display everything clearly on tables or blankets so it's easy to browse.


Price your items with simple, easy-to-read tags. Round numbers work best, and bundle pricing can encourage buyers to purchase more. Offering deals like "3 for $5" can help clear things out quickly. Make sure you have plenty of change or a mobile payment option available.


If you're participating in a neighborhood-wide sale in areas like Arvada or Broomfield, you’re likely to see higher foot traffic.


Step 3: Advertise Your Garage Sale

Promotion is key to drawing a crowd. Start spreading the word at least three to five days before the sale.


Post your garage sale on platforms like Facebook Marketplace, Nextdoor, and Craigslist. Be sure to include your city in the post title, for example, "Garage Sale - Longmont, Saturday 8AM", and upload photos of items you think will draw attention. In addition to online promotion, place signs with arrows near busy intersections to help direct traffic to your location.


Step 4: What to Do With Leftovers

Even with a successful sale, you’ll likely have items left over. The good news is you have a few great options.


If the items are in usable condition, consider donating them to organizations like https://www.habitat.org/restores, Goodwill, or ARC Thrift Stores. These organizations operate throughout Boulder, Longmont, and surrounding areas, and some offer pickup services.


For anything broken, outdated, or unsellable, Colorado Junk Runners can step in to haul it away quickly and responsibly. We proudly serve Lafayette, Erie, Longmont, Arvada, Berthoud, and nearby cities. We recycle and donate whatever we can, helping to keep unnecessary waste out of landfills.


Why Choose Colorado Junk Runners

We’re a locally owned and operated junk removal company serving Northern Colorado with reliable, eco-friendly service. Whether you have a few items left over from your sale or a larger cleanout project, we’re here to help.


Our team offers:


  • Same-day and next-day availability
  • Transparent pricing
  • Donation and recycling whenever possible
  • Friendly, professional service


Let us take the stress out of cleaning up after your sale so you can enjoy your newly reclaimed space.


Final Thoughts

A well-planned garage sale can help you clear out unwanted items, earn some extra cash, and take the first step toward a cleaner, more organized home. With the support of Colorado Junk Runners, getting rid of the leftover items is simple and stress-free.


If you're ready to book a pickup or want to learn more about our junk removal services, visit www.cojunkrunners.com.

You might also like

Colorado Junk Runners Blog

garage packed with clutter - decluttering vs storage unit decision
By Anne Callender June 6, 2025
Storage Unit vs. Decluttering: Do You Really Need Extra Space? Thinking about renting a storage unit because your home feels cluttered? You’re not alone. But before you sign that monthly contract, it’s worth asking: Do I really need more space… or just less stuff? In this post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of renting a storage unit vs. decluttering your space — and how simple junk removal could be the smarter, more affordable solution. Why People Rent Storage Units Renting a storage unit can seem like an easy fix when you're overwhelmed by too much stuff. Common reasons include: You're downsizing or in between homes You’ve inherited furniture or belongings You want to keep seasonal gear or holiday decorations out of sight You’re holding onto things “just in case” But storage units come with downsides: Monthly costs that add up fast Limited access to your belongings The risk of simply postponing a decluttering decision Decluttering: The More Permanent Solution Before renting a unit, take a step back and ask: Do I really want to keep all of this, or am I just avoiding sorting it? Decluttering your home often leads to the realization that: You don’t actually need most of what’s taking up space Letting go is more freeing (and cost-effective) than holding on A clean, organized home feels better than a paid storage bill Decluttering Tips to Get Started: Start with one area (like a garage or closet) Use the 1-year rule: if you haven’t used it in 12 months, let it go Separate items into keep, donate, sell, and toss piles Call in a junk removal team if the pile starts to feel overwhelming Junk Removal Services Make It Easy Decluttering can feel like a lot — especially when bulky items or large loads get in the way. That’s where Colorado Junk Runners comes in. We help homeowners throughout Boulder, Louisville, Lafayette, Erie, Longmont, and nearby areas remove everything from old furniture and appliances to yard waste, electronics, and household junk. We donate what we can, recycle responsibly, and make the whole process stress-free so you don’t have to lift a finger. FAQ: Storage Units vs. Decluttering Is decluttering cheaper than renting a storage unit? Yes — decluttering is typically a one-time effort, while storage units come with ongoing monthly fees. Junk removal may have a flat cost upfront, but it avoids long-term storage expenses. What should I do with large furniture or items I don’t want? Hire a junk removal service like Colorado Junk Runners. We handle everything from pickup to proper disposal or donation — no hauling or heavy lifting required. What if I still need short-term storage after decluttering? If you're moving or remodeling, consider a short-term storage solution like a portable container. But don’t commit to long-term storage until you’ve removed everything you truly don’t need. Final Thoughts: Choose Space That Serves You Before you commit to a storage unit, take a few hours to walk through your home and clear the clutter. You may discover that you don’t need more space — you just need less junk. Need help clearing the way? Colorado Junk Runners is here to help with reliable, eco-friendly junk removal across the Front Range. Whether you’re decluttering, downsizing, or just tired of tripping over old boxes, we’ll haul it away so you can enjoy a cleaner, more open space. Call or text us today at 303-885-2294 to get a free quote.
The back of a dump truck is filled with wooden boxes.
By Anne Callender April 23, 2025
Trying to decide between dumpster rental and junk removal in Colorado? Learn the pros, cons, and costs of each to choose the right cleanout solution for your home or project.
A junk runner truck is parked in the driveway of a house.
By Anne Callender April 7, 2025
Need junk removal near you in Colorado? Learn how to book fast, affordable pickup from a local team - plus how to save with curbside discounts.
More Posts

Book a Service Today